[Magic25]

From the most recent to the furthest I feel like going back lol.



I hate this one.

















































All the way back to the very first one I made.

[Sublimepwns_]

6/10 in my opinion

[CarlosJ]

good stuff i can really see how you have improved and started to refine your style a bit throughout the sigs.
i think what your work is lacking though is variety, although alot of some of your later work is of a kind of varied style it still has the same basics behind it, the similar sort of mono tonal colour in them all. on some this fits e.g. the hellgate one, however i think incorporating other colours into your work will help to give it more definition and variety. i think good examples of this are some of your more recent stuff, where it looks as though you've done alot of effort into the effects on the render and bits of blending around it, however the rest of your background seems to be lacking in as much thought (this may be an incorrect perception for me) it looks like after you've worked around the render you've added some very basic brush work and put an effect on it.

i'm not going to comment on alot of your early work as its irrelevant but regarding your half recent work with c4ds i feel there is a nice idea and thought behind them, however your techinique needs a bit of refining. i can see what youve tried to do on alot of the c4d pieces but the c4d is not supposed to be the background, it is supposed to contribute to the background to help with depth, you shouldnt be able to make out the entire c4d shape. apply c4ds on different layer types, add brush work and filters to them to help add variety to them and also so they are more subtle.

as a final note you need to work on text, alot of sigs lack text, they should have it even if its your name. then work on font choice, if its a technoy sig pick a techno sig, cartoon sig?; pick a bold cartoon sig. text also should be subtle, not the main focus of the sig so make sure its placed out of the main focal point and is not in a colour that contrasts the rest of the sig.

[Narudan]

I think the main critic point is, you overdid it in almost every sig^^

Too many Gradientmaps, Clippingmasks, too much/ not enough lightning and such, try to use other effects instead of one effect so much,

You're new sigs look alot better, i like the mario one most, but the color is too ..brown/pinkish

[Flipperfin]

Whoa, you've really improved a lot imo, I like the spiderman one a lot actually.

[xsyx]

pretty sick

[axxo135]

Hi MMOwned mate.
Can u make a sigill for me whit
http://i208.photobucket.com/albums/b...00/Shitsig.jpg

and i want te name ''Fikamondo'' whitout '''' ofc xD
I love u sig they are so nice u are good cya

[Ajuma]

Originally Posted by Sublimepwns_

6/10 in my opinion

Go kill yourself.

Anyways..

Hey man, those are amazing sigs right there, in fact some of those are the best ive ever seen, well done and keep up the hard work.

[Narudan]

Originally Posted by Ajuma

Go kill yourself.

Anyways..

Hey man, those are amazing sigs right there, in fact some of those are the best ive ever seen, well done and keep up the hard work.

Which one do you like so much, you tell someone who might know a lot more about sigs than you ,to kill himself?

[Mobbed]

They very from 5-7/10. Keep practicin', the first few are really tight, but they seem to deteriorate as they go.

Originally Posted by Ajuma

Go kill yourself.

Anyways..

Hey man, those are amazing sigs right there, in fact some of those are the best ive ever seen, well done and keep up the hard work.

Oh hi, Mr. 1 post. GTFO of the forums please, you obviously have very little understanding of graphics.

[Piersd]

*hides in a corner*

cmon people, he's asked for everyones opinion, not for people to flame or argue.


anyways, i can really see how you've improved. its alot like how i started, only i never used to use renders.

my favourite would have to be:

it has a nice flow, though i'm not quite a fan of the colours.

[Scuzzbuzz]

I must admit that the first few ones were amazing, it just seemed that after that a few of them was rushed.

But none the less some really really nice sigs there mate keep up the good work (Y)

[Magic25]

Thanks for the tips people.And they got worse as you went down it was basically a timeline of my sigs without dates :P.

[[Jwicky]]

Some of these are decent but then again some of the renders you chose to use in some of the art are what kills the image. Take your time with them, dont feel rushed and post up some fresh ones, keep at it.

[Wesk.]

Hmm dont really like anyone of them, 4/10